Excellence in academia emerges from deliberate practice

Most professions have clear paths for skills development. Athletes spend countless hours in the gym performing specific exercises. Musicians practice scales daily. Software developers break down complex problems into smaller chunks to master systematically.

But academics? We mostly just… do the work. Despite being professional knowledge workers, few of us dedicate time to deliberately improving our craft. We write papers but don’t practice writing. We think deeply but don’t systematically improve our thinking. We read constantly but rarely work on becoming better readers.

A mastery-approach to improvement

Consider how different fields approach expertise:

  • A professional musician might spend 2-3 hours daily on technical exercises
  • Elite athletes dedicate specific training sessions to individual skills
  • Software developers regularly participate in coding challenges and review sessions

Meanwhile, academics often fall into the trap of thinking that simply doing more academic work – writing more papers, attending more meetings, sending more emails – is the path to mastery.

What if we treated academic work more like a craft requiring deliberate practice? What would it look like to approach scholarly work with the same systematic attention to developing mastery that other professionals bring to their fields?

Deliberate practice in academia

The key is to break down the complex activities of academic work into smaller, practicable components:

  1. Writing skills practice
    • Spend 30 minutes each morning specifically practising writing introductions
    • Analyse 3-5 well-written introductions in your field weekly
    • Practice condensing complex ideas into clear, concise paragraphs
    • Keep a “writing improvement” journal to track your progress
  2. Reading and comprehension development
    • Dedicate 20 minutes to active reading techniques
    • Practice extracting key arguments from academic papers in under 10 minutes
    • Create a systematic method for note-taking and information extraction
    • Develop a personal system for quickly identifying a paper’s core thesis and methodology
  3. Analytical thinking
    • Set aside time to break down complex problems systematically
    • Practice generating alternative perspectives for research questions
    • Develop a routine for critically analysing research methodologies
    • Create mind maps or visual representations of complex academic concepts
  4. Skill integration techniques
    • Before reviewing a manuscript, spend 10 minutes practising critical analysis
    • When writing a paper introduction, first study the structure of top papers in your field
    • Use routine academic tasks as opportunities for deliberate skill improvement
    • Reflect on your work process after completing each major academic task
  5. Continuous improvement approach
    • Set monthly goals for specific skill improvements
    • Seek feedback from mentors or colleagues on your academic work
    • Regularly audit your academic skills and identify areas for development
    • Treat academic skill-building as a consistent, intentional practice

Remember, the goal is not to add more work to your schedule, but to be more intentional and systematic about how you approach your existing academic tasks. Small, consistent improvements can lead to significant long-term growth in your scholarly capabilities.

The beauty of this approach is that it doesn’t require extra hours in your day. Instead of adding new tasks to your schedule, it’s about being more intentional with the work you’re already doing. For example, if you’re reviewing a manuscript, take 10 minutes beforehand to practice extracting key arguments quickly and accurately. When writing your next paper introduction, spend the first 15 minutes studying the structure of three excellent introductions in your field. These small shifts in how you approach routine academic tasks can transform them into opportunities for deliberate practice.

At its core, mastering your academic craft is about treating knowledge work with the same deliberate attention that other professionals bring to their skills development. Excellence in academia isn’t just about working harder – it’s about the mundane and deliberate systematic practice aimed at enhancing the core skills that drive scholarly impact.


Are you ready to master your academic craft? The Career Development course helps transform your approach to academic work by focusing on building a long-term plan around a clearly defined strategic mission for your career.

Found this useful? Sign up to the Head Space newsletter for bi-weekly insights, or share it with your colleagues on social media.

More posts

Comments

Leave a comment